If
there is one thing that films like Platoon and Saving Private Ryan try to tell
us, it's that war is hell. This is certainly apparent in Ridley Scott's brutal
and violent Black Hawk Down. This re-enactment of a failed mission to Mogadishu,
Somalia in 1993 has no other purpose but to show us the absolute horror and chaos
that is war. The set up and introduction of the film's many characters lasts about
forty minutes. Once the helicopter goes down in Mogadishu, the bullets start flying
as a military helicopter unit find themselves under major siege.
The
cast includes many familiar faces. Tom Sizemore, William Fichtner and Ewan McGregor
are solid as vastly different men with a common purpose. Josh Hartnett fares much
better here then he did in the overbloated Pearl Harbor. And although he has an
all-too-small role, Eric Bana (Chopper) emerges as the standout in this huge ensemble.
Make
no mistakes. This is a director's movie. Forget the screenplay and the performances,
Ridley Scott is the real reason that this video works as well as it does. Once
he has the audience in his grasp, he refuses to let go. This video is ferocious
in it's execution rarely giving the audience a moment's rest. This is an ugly,
unflinching look at war in which men die without much of a warning.
Black
Hawk Down works better as a film than Scott's recent Gladiator and Hannibal, but
it still comes up shy of being the masterpiece he's capable of making (see Alien
or Bladerunner). After all is said and done, I wanted more out of Black Hawk Down.
It certainly doesn't sugar coat anything, but it also lacks an emotional core.
I didn't feel like I knew these men and that keeps the picture from being all
that it could've been. Of course, it could be argued that this video isn't really
about the soldiers but war itself. In that sense, Scott's visceral assault on
the audience delivers with unrelenting power.
